Skip to main content
Wisconsin Old Fashioned: How to Make (and Smoke) the Brandy Classic

Wisconsin Old Fashioned: How to Make (and Smoke) the Brandy Classic

By Middleton Mixology
10 min read
Share:

The Wisconsin Old Fashioned is not an Old Fashioned the way the rest of the country makes one. It is its own drink with its own rules, and people who grew up ordering them at supper clubs across the state tend to have strong opinions about every last detail.

Where the standard Old Fashioned is a spare drink built on whiskey, sugar, and bitters, the Wisconsin version starts with brandy, muddles in fresh citrus and a cherry, and finishes with a splash of soda. It is sweeter, fruitier, and louder than its bourbon cousin. That is not an accident or a shortcut. It is the point.

What the drink has never had is smoke. And that turns out to be a worthwhile addition, because brandy and wood smoke get along in ways most people have not tried yet.

What Makes a Wisconsin Old Fashioned Different

The differences are not subtle, and they start before you pick up a bottle.

Brandy, not bourbon. The base spirit is brandy, specifically American brandy, and in Wisconsin the default has been Korbel for decades. You will find variations made with bourbon or rye, but those are departures from the standard. The brandy gives the drink a softer, rounder body with more fruit character than a grain spirit provides.

Muddled fruit. A standard Old Fashioned gets an expressed orange peel as a garnish. The Wisconsin version muddles an orange slice and a maraschino cherry directly into the glass with the sugar and bitters, so the fruit is in the drink rather than on top of it.

Soda. The drink gets topped with a splash of soda, and the choice matters. "Sweet" means Sprite or 7-Up. "Sour" means Squirt or another grapefruit soda. "Press" means half sweet, half seltzer. And ordering it "old fashioned sour" at a Wisconsin supper club is a sentence that makes perfect sense to the bartender and baffles everyone from out of state.

The sugar cube stays. A sugar cube soaked in Angostura bitters is the traditional start. Simple syrup works and integrates faster, but the cube is part of the ritual, and ritual counts in a drink that is as much about the place as the flavor.

The Classic Recipe

Makes one cocktail.

Ingredients

  • 1 sugar cube (or 0.25 oz simple syrup)
  • 3 dashes Angostura bitters
  • 1 orange slice
  • 1 maraschino cherry (Luxardo or similar)
  • 2 oz brandy
  • Splash of lemon-lime soda, grapefruit soda, or seltzer
  • Ice

Method

  1. Place the sugar cube at the bottom of a rocks glass. Saturate it with the bitters.
  2. Add the orange slice and cherry. Muddle gently, enough to release the juice and oils but not so hard that you pulverize the orange pith, which turns the drink bitter.
  3. Add the brandy and stir briefly to combine.
  4. Fill the glass with ice, top with a splash of your chosen soda, and give it one more gentle stir.
  5. Garnish with a second orange slice and cherry if you like.

The drink should be colorful, slightly cloudy from the muddled fruit, and easy to sip. It is a porch drink and a supper club drink, not a craft bar meditation.

The Smoked Version

Here is where the drink picks up a dimension it never had in Wisconsin.

Brandy is built on distilled fruit, and fruit spirits take smoke beautifully. The soft grape and apple notes in the brandy meet the aromatic compounds in the wood, and the result is a drink that keeps its sweet, fruity character while gaining depth underneath.

Ingredients

  • 1 sugar cube
  • 3 dashes Angostura bitters
  • 1 orange slice
  • 1 maraschino cherry
  • 2 oz brandy
  • Splash of soda (your preference)
  • Cherry or apple wood chips

Method

  1. Build the drink in the classic method: muddle, add brandy, stir, and fill with ice. Hold the soda for now.
  2. Load a small pinch of wood chips into the SmokeTop Cocktail Smoker by Middleton Mixology chimney, roughly the volume of a cherry.
  3. Set the SmokeTop on the rim of the glass. Hold a butane torch about five inches above the chimney and direct the flame into the chips. Lower to two or three inches as the glass fills with thick white smoke.
  4. Lift the SmokeTop off, top with a splash of your chosen soda, and serve immediately. The smoke bonds to the liquid and the ice on contact, so the drink is ready the moment the smoker comes off, and adding the soda after the pass keeps the carbonation lively.

Discard the spent chips into a non-flammable container.

Choosing the Wood

The wood pairing changes the direction the drink takes, and brandy is accommodating enough to work with several options.

Cherry is the best starting point. Cherry wood carries a warm, subtly sweet smokiness that reinforces the cherry already muddled into the drink. The flavors stack rather than compete.

Apple reads orchard-bright and pairs naturally with brandy's grape-and-fruit base. This is the best option if you are making the "sour" (grapefruit soda) version, because the apple smoke bridges the fruit flavors.

Oak is the most neutral and barrel-forward option. It makes the smoked version taste closer to something aged, which works well if you are using a younger brandy that benefits from the suggestion of wood contact.

Maple pushes the drink toward autumn. If you want the Wisconsin Old Fashioned to feel like a fall cocktail, maple wood with a sugar cube does the work without adding maple syrup. The smoked maple Old Fashioned takes that direction further with bourbon.

The wood chip pairing guide covers each wood in detail and is worth reading before you stock up on chips.

The Brandy Question

In Wisconsin, the default brandy is Korbel. It has been the state's preferred brandy since the mid-twentieth century, and supper club bartenders pour it reflexively. It is a solid, affordable American brandy that does exactly what this drink needs.

Outside Wisconsin, you have more options and fewer expectations.

American brandy in the 80 proof range is the closest to the original intent. It runs fruit-forward and mild, which is the right baseline for a drink that already has muddled citrus and soda pulling it in a sweeter direction.

VSOP Cognac is a step up in complexity and cost. The brandy Old Fashioned recipe goes deeper on ratios and the Cognac versus brandy question. It works, but the delicacy of good Cognac can get lost underneath the muddled fruit and bitters. If you are using Cognac, consider the smoked version without the soda, which gives the spirit more room.

Apple brandy or Calvados makes a variation that leans hard into the orchard. This is a different drink in practice, but a good one, especially with apple wood smoke.

The one thing to watch is proof. A brandy below 80 proof gets diluted fast by the ice and the soda, and the smoke has less to hold onto. Stick with 80 proof or above.

Batching for a Group

The Wisconsin Old Fashioned batches well because it is already a forgiving, loose drink. Here is how to scale it.

For six servings: muddle six orange slices and six cherries with six sugar cubes and 18 dashes of bitters in a pitcher. Add 12 oz brandy and stir. Refrigerate until serving.

Pour over ice in individual glasses, smoke each glass individually with the SmokeTop, then top each with a splash of soda. Each glass gets its own smoke, which means each guest gets the full visual and aromatic experience rather than a diluted version from a pre-smoked batch.

This is a strong approach for a football weekend or a September gathering, especially if you set up the SmokeTop on the bar and let guests pick their own soda and wood chip.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is a Wisconsin Old Fashioned different from a regular Old Fashioned?

Three ways: brandy instead of bourbon or rye, muddled orange and cherry in the drink rather than as a garnish, and a splash of soda to finish. The result is sweeter, fruitier, and more textured than the standard recipe.

What does "sweet" or "sour" mean when ordering a Wisconsin Old Fashioned?

It refers to the soda. Sweet means lemon-lime soda like Sprite. Sour means grapefruit soda like Squirt. Press means half lemon-lime soda, half seltzer. You can also order it with just seltzer.

Are old fashioneds from Wisconsin?

The Old Fashioned cocktail predates Wisconsin's claim on it by decades, with roots in the late 1800s. What Wisconsin did was adopt brandy as the base spirit, add muddled fruit and soda, and make the result a regional institution. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned is a distinct regional variation, not the origin of the drink itself.

Can you smoke a brandy cocktail?

Brandy responds to wood smoke as well as bourbon does, sometimes better. Its fruit-forward character gives the smoke a softer landing, and the combination reads as more complex than either element alone. Cherry and apple wood are the strongest pairings for brandy.

What brandy do you use in a Wisconsin Old Fashioned?

Korbel is the traditional choice in Wisconsin. Any American brandy at 80 proof or above works well. VSOP Cognac and apple brandy are worthwhile variations, though they produce a different drink.

What wood chips are best for a smoked Wisconsin Old Fashioned?

Cherry is the best default because it reinforces the cherry already in the drink. Apple pairs naturally with brandy. Oak is the most neutral option.

What to Make Next

If you are exploring Old Fashioned variations, the smoked Old Fashioned covers the bourbon version from the ground up, and the smoked maple Old Fashioned is the best fall direction from here. The cocktail smoking guide goes deeper on technique if this is your first time working with a smoker.

Share:

Related Articles